The Story of James Hugney Sr.

Imagine serving 35 years 11 months and 8 days for a crime you did not commit. This is the story of James Hugney Sr.

Media Coverage of This Important Development

abc27 WHTM

Man released from prison in ’79 murder, arson case

abc27 WHTM

Attorney explains how science led to man’s release from prison

The Washington Post

This week in innocence: Joseph Sledge and James Hugney Sr.


Man freed after 35 years in prison for crime he did not commit‎

Free After 35 Years in Jail

Deal frees East Shore man from life prison sentence for fatal 1978 fire

Attorney for man freed after nearly 36 years in prison thankful ‘criminal justice system worked’

Forensic Magazine

Fire Science Advances Free Man after 35 Years in Prison

The Sentinel

Attorney: New evidence frees man in Dauphin County ’79 murder, arson case


James Hugney Sr. New developments in arson science that have led to..

Man Freed From Prison in 1979 Murder, Arson Case

Jornal SOL

Inocência provada após mais de 30 anos de prisão

Man Freed From Prison in 1979 Murder, Arson Case

(Harrisburg, PA and Bellefonte, PA)– In July 1979, James Hugney Sr. was convicted after a jury trial in Susquehanna Township, Dauphin County of a notorious arson-murder then called by the media “the Burning Bed Case” because of the prosecution’s theory of the case was that Hugney in a fit of anger set his house on fire by pouring flammable liquid around the bed of his then 16-year old son: his namesake James Hugney, Jr while his son slept in the bed. His house was gutted by the fire. Five days after the fire, his son died as a complication of his burns where he had 3rd degree burns over 98% of his body.

Fire experts at the time concluded that it was an arson based on “pour patterns”.  After his trial attorneys in 1979 did not challenge the opinions of the fire experts that it was an arson, James Hugney was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Every day for 36 years, Hugney has maintained his innocence.

In recent years, advancements in forensic science have shown that these previous methods of arson investigation were clearly wrong.  They were based on common beliefs at the time and were more myth than science.

Nearly four years ago, Attorney Justin J. McShane and the attorneys at The McShane Firm, LLC took up the investigation of Mr. Hugney’s conviction. Upon his initial review of the case, Attorney Justin J. McShane who is a well-known lawyer-scientist who focuses on forensic science related cases knew that “the science was wrong” in this case.

“The pivotal scientific evidence of negative corpus had been debunked,” said McShane, “and all of the scientific evidence used in the case was based on popularly held beliefs and myths of the time that modern science has totally refuted.” McShane retained 3 international fire scientists and all three of them independently and categorically stated that the scientific methods used to condemn Hugney to life in prison are not supported by modern science.

On January 23, 2015 James Hugney was given a new life. In an agreement with prosecutors, he was released from his life without the possibility of parole sentence.

“This is a great day for James Hugney, a great day for justice, and a great day for science,” said Hugney’s attorney, Justin McShane of The McShane Firm. “We give thanks to District Attorney Ed Marsico and First Assistant District Attorney Francis T. Chardo III who as honorable and noble shepherds of justice in Dauphin County did the right thing. Without them, justice would bot have been served in this case. It shows a remarkable sense of ethics and morality that these two are already well known for. While no one can give him back the nearly 36 years of his life that he lost, at least Mr. Hugney has his freedom now,” said McShane.

The entire family at The McShane Firm would like to congratulate James Hugney Sr. on his release.  He serves as an inspiration to us all and especially all of those wrongly convicted innocent people who are still fighting for their freedom.