Samuel Whalen Bio

The Government Has Its Story. Samuel Whalen Examines the Evidence.

When you’re accused of a crime, the government has police officers, investigators, prosecutors, and enormous resources working against you. Attorney Samuel Whalen believes you deserve someone who will examine every detail, challenge unsupported assumptions, and make the government prove its case.

A criminal charge can threaten your freedom, career, family, finances, and reputation.

And when the government presents its version of events, it can feel as though the outcome has already been decided.

But Samuel knows something important.

The government doesn’t always get it right.

Police officers can overlook evidence. Witnesses can misunderstand events. Reports can exaggerate certain details while ignoring others. And an investigation may leave important questions unanswered.

Samuel doesn’t approach criminal cases with panic or emotion.

He approaches them with preparation, persistence, and an almost microscopic attention to detail.

Because sometimes the smallest overlooked fact can change everything.

Reviews From Clients

Janet Hart

1 year ago

This firm was very professional and offered quick and thorough service and follow up. Answered all questions promptly and efficiently

Darryl Everett

1 year ago

I want to Thank you!!! For Believing in me I can honestly say, I Charged for Something I didnt do. Based on my past and prior convictions, it was Assumed I had a Dui, Thanks for not judging me as the officers did when pulled over...God knows and…

Matthew J Espenshade

2 years ago

Very professional. When it hits the fan and you need an attorney that will fight for your best interests call the McShane firm. You'll be glad you did.

Samantha Flanagan

2 years ago

The McShane firm helped our firm here in Rochester, NY answer some legal questions regarding DWI charges in NY for PA residents. We appreciate the assistance that we otherwise may have had to pay for! Thank you!

Michael Toomey

2 years ago

The McShane firm is the best in the business from start to finish. I would highly recommend them for anyone looking for Great results. They are true professionals that put their clients first and treat everyone with kindness and respect. I had an exceptional experience and I know…




He Finds the Evidence Others Miss.

One of Samuel’s greatest strengths is finding the needle in the haystack.

In cases he has handled, Samuel has located third-party surveillance footage that police investigators overlooked. That footage contradicted important witness statements and materially strengthened the defense.

It wasn’t evidence handed to him by the prosecution.

It required looking beyond what the government had already collected.

Samuel believes that distinction matters.

A police investigation is not necessarily a complete investigation.

He examines reports, studies available recordings, evaluates witness accounts, and looks for inconsistencies that others may have missed.

He also takes time to understand what witnesses actually observed and meant to communicate, rather than simply accepting their initial statements at face value.

Because the government’s case may sound convincing until someone asks the right question.


Serious PFA Allegations. Successful Defenses.

Samuel has also achieved favorable results defending clients in Protection From Abuse proceedings.

PFA allegations can carry serious consequences, potentially affecting a person’s home, family relationships, firearms rights, and reputation.

In several matters, Samuel faced accusations that initially appeared extremely damaging to his clients.

Rather than becoming distracted by the emotional nature of the allegations, he carefully examined the evidence, identified weaknesses in the opposing narrative, and prepared to challenge the claims in court.

His work resulted in requested PFA orders not being granted.

Those outcomes reinforce his approach to criminal defense.

An accusation can sound compelling without being supported by sufficient evidence.

Samuel understands that every case is different and no result can be guaranteed. But he believes even the most troubling allegations deserve objective examination before conclusions are reached.


In DUI Defense, the Video May Tell a Different Story.

DUI prosecutions often rely heavily on police observations.

An officer may describe a motorist as confused, unsteady, or impaired. Those descriptions can appear convincing in a written report.

But Samuel wants to see what actually happened.

He carefully reviews available body-camera and dashboard-camera recordings, sometimes spending hours examining details that a casual viewing could miss.

Did the driver follow instructions?

Was the officer’s description consistent with the video?

Did the motorist demonstrate normal coordination or behavior that the report failed to mention?

Were certain observations emphasized while contradictory evidence was overlooked?

Samuel doesn’t just look for what the driver allegedly did wrong. He looks at everything the driver did right.

That matters because the government must prove impairment under the applicable law, not simply identify a few observations it considers suspicious.

Samuel believes the entire encounter deserves examination.


Field Sobriety Tests Are Not Beyond Challenge.

Samuel has developed detailed worksheets to evaluate the administration and interpretation of individual standardized field sobriety tests.

He uses them to examine the officer’s instructions, demonstrations, testing conditions, reported clues, and adherence to applicable standardized procedures.

He compares those observations against available video evidence.

The purpose is to identify potential departures from testing standards, inconsistencies, and circumstances that may affect the reliability or significance of the results.

At The McShane Firm, Samuel combines that detailed approach with a team known for its focus on DUI science, including breath testing, blood testing, forensic evidence, and police procedures.

A police officer’s conclusion is not the end of the investigation. It’s a conclusion that must be tested against the evidence.


Calm, Objective, and Honest About Your Options.

Samuel doesn’t believe clients benefit from an attorney who becomes emotionally overwhelmed by their cases.

His strength is remaining calm, analyzing the facts objectively, and identifying realistic ways to eliminate or minimize potential consequences.

He understands that clients are often frightened.

They worry about jail, their driver’s licenses, and their jobs.

But Samuel also recognizes that criminal charges can create deeper concerns.

Will I recover financially?

What will this do to my family?v

How will I rebuild my life?

He takes those concerns seriously while maintaining the objectivity necessary to evaluate the case.

Samuel also believes clients deserve candid advice.

He will explain the strengths and weaknesses of the evidence, the possible outcomes, and the risks associated with different decisions.

He won’t promise a result he cannot support.

And he won’t simply agree with a proposed strategy if he believes it is unrealistic.

His job is not to tell you what you want to hear. His job is to give you the information you need to make sound decisions about your future.

Your goals matter. Your decisions matter. And you deserve an attorney who explains your options without false promises.


Years of Public Defense Experience. A Team Behind Him.

Before joining The McShane Firm, Samuel spent many years working at the Erie County Public Defender’s Office.

That experience exposed him to a broad range of criminal charges and clients from different backgrounds.

It taught him the importance of patience, objective judgment, and understanding each person’s individual circumstances.

Today, Samuel works closely with his paralegal, Kyra, and the attorneys and staff at The McShane Firm.

He values the firm’s collaborative approach because criminal defense often requires examining legal, scientific, factual, and practical questions from multiple perspectives.

When you hire Samuel, you’re not hiring an attorney who works alone. You’re gaining a defense team.

The firm’s Client Bill of Rights also establishes clear expectations for proactive communication, prompt responses, professional preparation, straight answers, and keeping clients informed.

Samuel believes those commitments matter, particularly when a client is making decisions that could affect the rest of their life.


Persistent in His Work. Disciplined in His Approach.

Outside the courtroom, Samuel enjoys running.

It’s an activity that rewards discipline, consistency, and the willingness to keep going when the work becomes difficult.

Those same qualities shape his legal practice.

Reviewing hours of video. Comparing witness statements. Following up on overlooked evidence. Examining the details of a field sobriety test.

Much of that work happens long before a courtroom appearance.

But Samuel believes it’s where meaningful defenses are built.

He describes himself as intensely competitive. He wants to win, and he is persistent in pursuing every legitimate opportunity to strengthen a client’s position.

That determination is balanced by a realistic understanding of the law, the evidence, and the possible outcomes.


Your Future Is Too Important for a Quick Review.

If you’re facing DUI or criminal charges, you may feel like the government has already decided what happened.

Samuel Whalen doesn’t assume the police report tells the whole story.

He wants to know what the evidence actually proves.

What the witnesses may have missed.

What the video reveals.

And whether there is a stronger path forward than the one the prosecution is offering.

He cannot promise a dismissal, acquittal, or particular sentence.

But he can bring years of criminal defense experience, careful preparation, candid advice, and persistent advocacy to your case.

The government has its investigators. You deserve someone who will investigate the government’s case.

If you’re facing criminal or DUI charges in Central Pennsylvania, contact The McShane Firm to discuss your options.

Call (717) 657-3900 or request a consultation.